Ombudsman

2022 - 3 - 4

Post cover
Image courtesy of "The Straits Times"

Who guards the guards, asks Shanmugam in rebutting WP MP's call ... (The Straits Times)

SINGAPORE - Home Affairs Minister K. Shanmugam on Thursday (March 3) rebutted the call by Workers' Party (WP) MP Leon Perera (Aljunied GRC) for an ombudsman, ...

Maybe Mr Perera hasn’t understood the constitutional structure and how the CPIB can go directly to the President.” In the current climate, there is more of a need for this," he added, saying this would be similar to the practice in New Zealand. This is similar to Mr Perera’s suggestion, he added, saying: “I have explained how that is so. Rather than having a proper legal process, including a complaint system, an independent investigation set up, say by the police, with some outside people sitting on it, or judicial review." Say you have an organisation where the top leaders engage in wrongdoing, or for example, say they set up a disciplinary committee to cover up what they did rather than actually investigate. Singapore's system already provides many processes to check on wrongdoing including by the Government, whether it is corruption or foreign interference, said the minister.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "CNA"

'Makes no sense': Shanmugam rebuts WP MP's suggestion for ... (CNA)

SINGAPORE: In his speech debating the Home Affairs Ministry's budget, Workers' Party Member of Parliament (MP) Leon Perera on Thursday (Mar 3) asked how ...

That has advantages in terms of the strength and solidarity of our polity. We institutionalise it such that the CPIB can go straight to the Prime Minister, but where the Prime Minister himself is the possible subject of investigations, or if the Prime Minister doesn't want to do something, the CPIB can go to the President. Being seen to do that has advantages in terms of accountability that is felt by the society. Maybe Mr Perera hasn’t understood the constitutional structure and how the CPIB can go directly to the President. Thank you, sir. And if they believe that the higher authority is not acting properly, they can take it up all the way. They are within that command and control hierarchy, at the end of the day. Mr Perera’s suggestion, if I understood him correctly, is that why not we set up a separate ombudsman with the resources to carry out all these investigations? And I explained how the system works and the Prime Minister can be the subject of independent investigations. Now, take a hypothetical situation - say an organisation where the top leaders engage in wrongdoing, or for example, say they set up a disciplinary committee to cover up what they did rather than actually investigate, I think you can ask “quis custodiet ipsos custodes”. And if Mr Perera was part of any such organisation, we'll be the first one to make such a point. In the current climate, there is more of a need for this. The world is changing and geopolitical tensions are ratcheting up to levels that have not been seen in recent memory. Or for example, say they set up a disciplinary committee to cover up what they did rather than actually investigate, I think you can ask Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?

Explore the last week